Baked Mahi Mahi Recipe with Lemon Butter Sauce

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.

This baked mahi mahi recipe is so simple and delicious you won’t believe it! Also very quick – taking only 30 minutes start to finish!

With the sumptuous creamy lemon butter sauce added before baking, you will have a flavorful fish dinner ready in less than an hour.

Great served over rice, pasta, or all by itself with a side salad or vegetables of choice.

What You’ll Need:

• 1 pound fresh mahi mahi, skin removed (four 4-ounce portions)
• 2 medium lemons, zest and juice
• 1/2 cup heavy cream
• 2 Tbsp butter
• 2 Tbsp olive or avocado oil (or oil of choice)
• 1/2 tsp salt
• 1/4 tsp ground black pepper
• 1 tsp dry thyme
• 1 tsp minced garlic (about 1 large clove)

Tips for the Best Baked Mahi Mahi

Mahi mahi is a very delicious white fish that’s similar in texture (in my opinion) to salmon. Nice large flakes and a mild flavor.

It’s a larger fish, so it’s not as easy to overcook as some smaller fish like flounder.

However, beware of overcooking, as this will leave your fish dry and less flavorful. The lemon and cream sauce will help with this, but getting both right will result in spectacular results.

The fresher your fish, the better your baked mahi dish! I actually made this recipe the first time with fresh-and-never-frozen mahi mahi.

But the second time, I used frozen, and the results were the same. Just make sure that your mahi is mostly defrosted when beginning the cooking process.

If it’s partially frozen and still has the skin on, take this time to remove the skin with a sharp knife. It will be easier than removing from fully thawed fish.

You can also opt to leave the skin on and position the fish skin-side down when cooking.

Making the Creamy Lemon Butter Sauce

The lemon butter sauce is the secret ingredient to making this baked mahi mahi supreme! It’s simple to make but full of flavorful ingredients that will take your fish to the next level.

Melting the butter first is pretty important, so that you can then mix the rest of the ingredients thoroughly, making a nice pourable sauce mixture.

Get the sauce mixture a bit bubbly, but don’t boil. What I mean is – get it just starting to bubble and then remove it from the heat.

You don’t want the cream to boil (as it will curdle and not be as smooth), but it’s okay to get hot enough to bubble. If it happens to curdle a bit, this won’t affect the taste – just the look of it.

Don’t miss the extra tips and FAQs below the recipe!

Print Recipe

5 from 7 votes

Baked Mahi Mahi Recipe with Creamy Lemon Butter Sauce

Prep Time5 mins

Cook Time25 mins

Total Time30 mins

Course: Main Course

Cuisine: American

Servings: 4 servings

Author: Savory With Soul

Ingredients

• 1 pound fresh mahi mahi, skin removed (four 4-ounce portions)
• 2 medium lemons, zest and juice
• 1/2 cup heavy cream
• 2 Tbsp butter
• 2 Tbsp olive or avocado oil (or oil of choice)
• 1/2 tsp salt
• 1/4 tsp ground black pepper
• 1 tsp dry thyme
• 1 tsp minced garlic (about 1 large clove)

Instructions

• Preheat oven to 450 F.
• In a small sauce pan, melt butter on low heat. Add garlic, thyme, lemon juice and zest, and cream and cook until a bit bubbly but not boiling (about 5 minutes). Remove from heat.
• Add oil to iron skillet or 6 x 9 oven-safe dish and arrange fish on top of oil. Pour butter mixture over top of fish. Cover and cook 15 minutes.
• Uncover and cook another 5 minutes to brown a bit.
• Remove from the oven and let sit 5-10 minutes before serving.
• Serve over rice or pasta, spooning sauce generously over top of fish.
• Leftovers can be safely kept in the refrigerator up to 3 days.

What to Serve with Baked Mahi Mahi

Serve this baked mahi mahi recipe with rice or pasta and a side salad or green vegetable. I served mine over Lundberg Jubilee Rice along with a simple spring mix side salad.

I also recommend my easy Strawberry Spinach Salad, my quick Green Beans Almondine, or my Cast Iron Brussel Sprouts.

You may also want to consider my Cream Style Corn or Cream of Peas.

More FAQs

Can I bake mahi mahi with the skin on?

Yes, you can! Make sure to cook with the skin side down, as this will make sure your fish is nicely browned on the top. You can easily avoid the skin when eating by plucking each bite from the top.

Do I need to remove the skin before serving?

No, the fish will be just fine to serve with the skin on. Just make sure the skin is on the bottom and not the top. Like above, it’s pretty easy to avoid eating the skin when taking bites from the top of the fish.

How can I tell if my mahi mahi is fresh?

I mostly judge my fish by smell. If it smells extra “fishy,” you know it’s not the freshest. It should still be okay as long as you’re going by the sell-by or use-by date.

However, if your fish smells like ammonia, you should probably discard it. Fresh fish will not smell extra fishy, but it will smell like the sea – like saltwater and the ocean.

Can I use other types of fish for this recipe?

Mahi mahi is not a fatty fish like salmon, so it won’t taste like a fatty fish. It’s best compared to a mild white fish like cod, halibut, swordfish, red snapper, or grouper.

Keep in mind that thinner cuts of fish will need less cook time, so plan accordingly. My mahi is typically about 1/2 to 3/4 inch thick. If your fish is thinner, it will need less cook time to avoid overcooking.

How do I know if my fish is overcooked?

If your fish is overcooked, it will be tough. Properly cooked fish is tender and soft but not overly soft. It’s better to err on the side of softer, as you can always cook it a bit more.

If it’s overcooked, however, it will be a bit chewy. It’s still okay to eat, but may not be as enjoyable or flavorful.

More Dinner Recipe Ideas:

• Spaghetti Bolognaise (Southern Style, of course!)
• Chicken & Bacon Pasta Bake
• Corn Potato Chowder (Easy, Hearty & Delicious!)
• Authentic Jambalaya Recipe (Lots of Spicy Flavors!)
• Turkey Ala King (Using Leftover Turkey or Chicken)
• London Broil Crock Pot Recipe (with Built-In Gravy)

Don’t Forget To Pin for Later!